The 2012 documentary is a remarkable piece of filmmaking that introduced millions of people to a case they would not otherwise have encountered. It is also a text that requires critical reading. The reenactment sequences are not archival footage. The moments in which Bourdin speaks most directly about the family’s alleged knowledge are moments in which the film is relying entirely on the word of a convicted fraudster. The film does not simply endorse Bourdin’s allegations, but it gives them space and presence. Viewers who watch the film and walk away believing the family was complicit in Nicholas’s death are drawing a conclusion that the evidence does not establish, though the film’s structure makes that conclusion feel available.
This is a tension inherent in a certain kind of documentary storytelling, the kind that uses a complicated and self-aware subject to explore questions that exceed any individual’s ability to answer. The Imposter is valuable and worth watching. It is also worth watching with an awareness of what it is doing and what it cannot prove.
—
## The Ear Comparison Method in Historical Context
Charlie Parker’s reliance on ear analysis as his initial investigative tool deserves a few additional words of context. The specific claim that ear morphology is unique and stable enough to serve as an identification tool has a history in forensic science. Researchers in the Netherlands published studies in the 1990s suggesting that ear morphology could be used to distinguish individuals. This research was used in some European criminal cases during the same period.
