—
## Jason Barclay and the September Sighting
The claim made by Jason Barclay in September 1994, approximately three months after Nicholas disappeared, that he had seen his brother attempting to break into the family garage, is one of the more scrutinized elements of the Barclay disappearance record. Jason told police that he had observed Nicholas at the garage late at night. Nicholas had apparently noticed he was being watched and fled. Police investigated but found no trace of Nicholas in the area, no other witnesses who had seen him, and no physical evidence consistent with the sighting.
The family’s own response to Jason’s account was divided. Some accounts suggest that Beverly wanted to believe the sighting was real, that it meant Nicholas was alive and in the area. Others suggest that members of the family had doubts. Police found the sighting questionable given the lack of corroboration and the absence of any subsequent contact or confirmed location.
Jason Barclay died in 1998. He was, by accounts of the period, struggling with drug problems. His death came within weeks of investigative interviews conducted by FBI agent Nancy Fisher and private investigator Charlie Parker in the aftermath of Bourdin’s exposure. Those interviews were exploring the circumstances of Nicholas’s original disappearance. The timing of Jason’s death relative to those interviews has been noted in accounts of the case. The death was attributed to a cocaine overdose, and no foul play in connection with his death was established or pursued publicly.
What investigators were specifically asking Jason about in those post-Bourdin-exposure interviews is not fully detailed in public reporting. The reasonable inference is that the exposure of Bourdin raised new questions about the family’s circumstances around the time of Nicholas’s disappearance, questions that investigators wanted to explore directly with family members who had been present. Jason was the last documented person to have direct contact with Nicholas on the night he disappeared, in the sense that he received Nicholas’s phone call and declined to wake Beverly. He was also the person who reported the unconfirmed garage sighting three months later.
