The specific federal charges Bourdin faced, passport fraud and perjury, reflect the particular nature of his crimes as they intersected with federal jurisdiction. Identity fraud in the United States can be prosecuted at the state or federal level depending on what specific laws were violated and which documentation was falsified.
Bourdin’s crimes touched federal jurisdiction at multiple points. The U.S. passport that was obtained for him based on false identity constituted passport fraud under federal law. The sworn statements he made to federal officials and in federal proceedings constituted perjury. These were the charges that produced his conviction and his six-year sentence.
The sentence of six years was described in reports as significantly exceeding what the federal sentencing guidelines would have suggested for those specific offenses. Federal judges have discretion to depart from guidelines when circumstances warrant, and the circumstances here were not standard. A person who deceived a grieving family about the return of their missing child, who obtained an American passport through fraud, who lived for five months in a family home under a false identity, and who triggered a federal investigation that consumed significant resources was not a standard passport fraud defendant. The sentence reflected judicial assessment of the severity and audacity of the conduct.
Bourdin served his sentence and was deported to France. The deportation was not a punishment beyond the criminal sentence. It was the standard consequence for a foreign national convicted of federal crimes in the United States. Bourdin had no legal basis for remaining in the country, and his deportation was administratively straightforward.
