The Hard Copy segment was shot during this period. Beverly’s visits with the person claiming to be her son were happening during this period. Parker was conducting his surveillance operations during this period. Bourdin was attending to the daily requirements of maintaining a false identity in a context where that identity had specific obligations: Nicholas Barclay had a mother, a sister, a family history, a school history, a neighborhood. Bourdin had none of these things and had to navigate around the gaps.
Accounts from the period, drawn from later interviews and from the documentary, describe the person claiming to be Nicholas as avoiding situations where his ignorance of the real Nicholas’s history would be exposed. Beverly’s later account that he became very upset when she took him to John Wood Middle School, the school Nicholas had attended, suggests that these avoidance strategies were not always successful. His upset in that moment could reflect any number of things: awareness that the building’s unfamiliarity to him was visible to Beverly, anxiety that the deception was nearing collapse, or the specific psychological pressure of being a fraud in a context where the fraud was becoming increasingly fragile.
Beverly’s statement that he “just didn’t act like my son” is the clearest indication in the public record of her private experience of the five-month period. It is a statement that speaks to behavioral and character-level differences rather than physical ones. Nicholas, as Beverly knew him, would have had specific mannerisms, specific ways of interacting with family members, specific emotional responses, specific memories and references to their shared history. The person in her home had none of these. He was performing a character he had constructed from a faxed file, not drawing on actual memories of a shared life.
