It is also worth noting that the photograph comparison that might have made identification more rigorous was complicated by the same factors that complicated every visual comparison in the case: Nicholas had been 13 at disappearance, was nominally 16 at the time of Bourdin’s presentation, and three years of adolescent development could account for many changes. Carey was not looking at her brother as she last saw him. She was looking at someone she was told was her brother after three and a half years of absence and a traumatic captivity.

—

## The Impact on Beverly Dollarhide

Beverly Dollarhide’s life over the course of the Barclay case, from Nicholas’s disappearance through the Bourdin impersonation and its exposure, was one of sustained trauma and upheaval. She had lost a child to an unexplained disappearance, rebuilt her life through recovery from addiction, received a person claiming to be her returned child, lived with that person for five months, and then had the impersonation exposed. She had also, through the process of investigation following Bourdin’s arrest, been subjected to polygraph examinations and investigative questioning about whether she had any knowledge of or involvement in Nicholas’s fate.

The specific psychological weight of these experiences is not something the public record can fully convey. What is documented is that Beverly made public statements about the case in various contexts, including in the documentary, and that those statements reflected a mix of genuine grief, confusion, and some degree of continued uncertainty about what she believed and what she knew.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.