The Bourdin case matters not just as a story about an extraordinary impostor but as a story about the lasting significance of an unresolved disappearance. Nicholas Barclay would be in his mid-40s today if he is still alive. The case that bears his name is primarily classified, in the public imagination, as the Bourdin impersonation case, the story of The Imposter. The 2012 documentary title encapsulates this classification: the subject of the film, in its framing, is Bourdin, the impostor, rather than Barclay, the missing child.

This classification is understandable. Bourdin’s story is dramatic, documented, and has a resolution of sorts: fraud exposed, perpetrator convicted. Nicholas’s story is tragic, undocumented beyond the initial disappearance, and has no resolution. Compelling narratives tend to coalesce around the parts that have shape and outcome. The part of this story that has shape and outcome is Bourdin. The part that does not, the original disappearance of a troubled 13-year-old, is the foundation everything else rests on.

Nicholas Barclay’s missing persons listing remains active. Organizations that track cold cases periodically revisit the case in the context of new DNA technologies and new investigative tools that were not available in 1994 or 1998. If Nicholas’s remains were found in a location that could be searched with modern methods, DNA comparison would be possible. If a person with knowledge of Nicholas’s fate were to come forward, the case could move. Neither of these things has happened, as of the time of this article’s research.

The case occupies a particular place in the literature of missing persons, true crime, and identity fraud: a case with a dramatic false resolution, a conviction, an international audience, and an underlying mystery that none of that drama and documentation has actually resolved. It is a case that illustrates both the ingenuity of a specific fraudster and the ongoing uncertainty at the heart of an ordinary disappearance that happened three decades ago on the northwest side of San Antonio, Texas.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.