Whatever the internal workings of Carey’s decision, its legal consequence was significant. Her sworn identification provided the basis for a court in Spain to certify the young man as an American citizen and issue him documents for travel. He boarded a plane with Carey and arrived in San Antonio.

—

## Five Months on Vance Jackson Road

The person claiming to be Nicholas Barclay moved into the family home in the northwest part of San Antonio. Beverly Dollarhide, the family’s mother, had been in recovery from addiction for the years her son was missing. She was now working and trying to put her life back together. The return of her son, in the narrative she was accepting, was an extraordinary development. By accounts drawn from multiple sources and from the documentary record, she embraced him. He lived in the home as a family member. He ate meals with the family. He was enrolled or placed in contexts appropriate for a returning teenager.

He continued to tell the story he had rehearsed: captivity by traffickers, being transported across Europe, eventually escaping and making contact with Spanish authorities. He said the eye drops that changed his eye color had been a form of control. He said he had been forced to adopt a French accent and speaking patterns. He maintained these explanations through weeks and then months. Beverly Dollarhide, in comments documented later in news reports and in the film that covered the case, said that the person in her home never quite acted like her son. The mannerisms were off. The accent never went away. The emotional connection she expected to feel was elusive. But she also said she wanted to believe. She had grieved her son’s absence for three years, and the alternative interpretation of the person sitting at her table, speaking with a French accent, was too terrible to accept.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.