Parker concluded that the ears did not match. The person in the film was not, in Parker’s assessment, Nicholas Barclay. He took his concerns to Beverly Dollarhide. He also began conducting what amounted to a surveillance operation, spending time around the young man, observing his behavior, looking for other inconsistencies. He maintained contact with the person claiming to be Nicholas, meeting him regularly, including on multiple occasions at a local diner where the two of them had breakfast together. Parker’s approach was methodical rather than confrontational in the early stages. He was building a picture.
Nancy Fisher, an FBI agent assigned to the case, was also examining the situation by this point. Fisher had her own concerns. Among other observations, Fisher noted that the hair roots of the person claiming to be Nicholas did not match the blond color he was presenting. The roots showed darker hair growing in underneath, suggesting recent dyeing. The inconsistencies were accumulating not just in Parker’s private investigation but within the official federal inquiry.
—
## The Formal Investigation Closes In
The FBI sought and obtained a court order for formal identification of the person claiming to be Nicholas Barclay. According to Wikipedia’s documented account of the case, the court order authorized the collection of fingerprints and DNA. The official identification process that followed established what Parker had suspected and what Fisher had been investigating: the person living in the Barclay family home was not Nicholas Barclay. His fingerprints did not match any records for Nicholas Barclay. His DNA did not match the family’s.
