After completing the painting, he baked it, cracked it, and inked the cracks. He then applied varnish and distressed the surface further to match the visual condition of a genuinely old painting. He had a piece of the original canvas remaining, which he kept.

He needed a path to Bredius. He used an intermediary — a lawyer who had agreed to present the painting as belonging to an anonymous Italian family of Dutch descent. The story was not elaborate. It didn’t need to be. The painting, once it was before Bredius, would do the work.

—

## Why Bredius Was Convinced

Bredius’s authentication of the *Supper at Emmaus* was not careless in the sense of being rushed or inattentive. He was a careful examiner by the standards of his field and his era. But his field’s standards did not require the chemical and physical analysis that would eventually expose van Meegeren’s technique, and his era did not yet have the institutional protocols that would make such analysis routine.

The method Bredius applied — the connoisseur’s eye — was what the field had relied on for generations. It involved comparing the work under examination against known authentic examples, assessing the handling of paint, the composition, the palette, the specific mannerisms that an individual painter developed and repeated across a lifetime’s work. Applied by someone with Bredius’s depth of knowledge, this method had a genuine track record of identifying both genuine works and fakes. He had made real discoveries. He had also caught real fakes.

What the method could not reliably do was identify a forgery specifically constructed by someone who had studied its limitations. Van Meegeren had spent six years learning exactly what a connoisseur of Bredius’s generation would look for, and exactly what materials and techniques would produce a painting that satisfied those criteria. He had addressed the specific tests that Bredius would apply — the needle test, the visual inspection, the stylistic comparison — by creating a forgery that passed all of them.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.