Van Meegeren was arrested in Amsterdam in May 1945. The charge was collaboration with the enemy — specifically, the sale of Dutch national cultural property to agents of the Nazi occupation. In the Netherlands in 1945, with the memories of occupation still raw and the full extent of what the Nazis had done to the country and to its Jewish community fully apparent, collaboration was not a minor charge. It carried the possibility of a death sentence.

The specific logic of the charge was that selling a Dutch Old Master to a Nazi official, even through intermediaries, constituted collaboration with the looting of Dutch cultural property. Van Meegeren’s defense — that the painting was actually a modern forgery he had made himself, that he had therefore not transferred genuine Dutch cultural property to Göring but had instead tricked him — was, initially, not believed.

The claim was extraordinary. The painting had been authenticated. The Rijksmuseum’s acquisition of a different “Vermeer” from the same forger had not raised serious doubts. Art experts who were contacted by the authorities confirmed that the works attributed to van Meegeren as forgeries were genuine Old Masters. The idea that a Dutch painter who had spent his career being dismissed as derivative could have produced forgeries convincing enough to fool the entire Dutch art establishment was met with considerable skepticism.

—

## The Confession and the Problem of Being Believed

Van Meegeren confessed on June 12, 1945, approximately two weeks after his arrest. He told investigators that he had not sold a Vermeer to Göring’s agents — he had sold a forgery he had painted himself. He further claimed that he had also forged several other works that had been authenticated as genuine Vermeers and genuine de Hooches and were currently in Dutch public and private collections.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.