—
## The Supper at Emmaus After the War
The *Supper at Emmaus* remains in the collection of the Museum Boijmans Van Beuningen. It is currently held in storage in the museum’s depot, though it has been displayed at various points since the war, including loans to other institutions.
The museum’s posture toward the painting is something more complex than simple embarrassment. The work is exhibited, when it is exhibited, as a document of one of the most significant cases of art forgery in the twentieth century — a demonstration of what a skilled forger working with deep knowledge of his target’s style and his audience’s assumptions could accomplish.
The painting is not presented as a Vermeer — it is presented as a van Meegeren. The distinction matters: the work that the museum owns is precisely the same physical object that hung as a celebrated discovery in 1937. What changed is the attribution. The paint, the canvas, the craquelure, the *pointillés* on the bread — all of that is unchanged. What changed is the name in the label.
—
## Why It Worked: Attribution, Authority, and the Limits of the Connoisseur’s Eye
The van Meegeren case is frequently discussed as an illustration of a vulnerability in the system of art authentication — specifically, the vulnerability of attribution that depends too heavily on the judgment of individual experts rather than on physical and chemical analysis.
This reading is accurate as far as it goes, but it underestimates the specific and deliberate nature of van Meegeren’s targeting. He did not succeed by producing a generically good forgery and presenting it to random experts. He succeeded because he had studied the specific expert he was targeting, identified the specific theoretical framework that would make that expert most receptive, and constructed a painting that confirmed that framework in its stylistic and compositional choices.
