Bredius’s enthusiasm for the Emmaus was not purely a failure of technical rigor. It was the result of a skilled forger exploiting a specific intellectual predisposition in a specific way. The painting confirmed a theory Bredius had already published. It filled a gap in a catalogue that he had spent years analyzing. It appeared at a moment when Bredius’s own authority made it very difficult for other scholars to voice skepticism about an attribution he had personally endorsed.

The subsequent buyers and institutions that acquired other van Meegeren forgeries were responding to a different form of institutional authority: the fact that the Emmaus had been authenticated and acquired by the Boijmans, and the works from the same intermediary networks had a track record of being what they were claimed to be. Each successful sale made the next one easier, because each represented a prior authentication that subsequent buyers could rely on.

The forensic tools that eventually exposed van Meegeren’s technique — the identification of phenol formaldehyde resin in the paint, the detection of cobalt blue anachronisms, the X-ray evidence of modern canvas preparation — were available, in principle, before the war. Chemical analysis of paint composition had been practiced in art investigation since the nineteenth century. What had not happened was the routine application of such analysis to works authenticated by recognized authorities. The institutional assumption was that Bredius’s eye could be trusted, and that testing a Bredius authentication was unnecessary.

Van Meegeren’s case contributed directly to changing that assumption. After 1947, the expectation that attributions of major Old Master works should be supported by physical and chemical analysis as well as connoisseurial judgment became progressively more embedded in museum and auction practice. The specific anachronisms that exposed van Meegeren’s forgeries — materials that did not exist in the seventeenth century — remain among the most reliable forensic markers that investigators look for in potential forgeries.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.