—
## The Coremans Analysis and Its Lasting Significance
Paul Coremans’s post-trial investigation — his systematic chemical and physical examination of the contested works — was important not only for its specific findings in the van Meegeren case but for establishing a methodological model for how forensic analysis could be applied to disputed attributions.
His published report, which documented the specific anachronisms found in each examined work, demonstrated that scientific evidence could establish attribution questions that connoisseurial judgment had failed to resolve. The phenol formaldehyde resin was not ambiguous. The cobalt blue was not ambiguous. The canvas evidence was not ambiguous. Each of these findings represented a form of evidence that was categorically different from the visual judgment of a connoisseur — it was evidence that van Meegeren’s own technique and materials had preserved against his will, written into the paint in terms that chemistry could read.
The subsequent application of lead-210 radioactive dating to Vermeer attributions — developed at Carnegie Mellon University and applied to disputed works from the 1960s onward — extended this methodology further. White lead pigment, produced from lead ore, contains a specific radioactive isotope (lead-210) whose decay rate can be measured. Because the ore processing that produces white lead removes a related element (radium-226), the amount of lead-210 remaining in the pigment decreases at a predictable rate after processing. Measuring the residual lead-210 allows researchers to estimate when the pigment was processed — and therefore whether a painting claiming to be from the seventeenth century could actually be three hundred years old, or whether its pigment was manufactured more recently.
