This technique, applied to works associated with van Meegeren’s production, confirmed the conclusions Coremans had reached through chemical means. The combined forensic picture was unambiguous.

—

## The Role of Desire in Attribution

One dimension of the van Meegeren case that continues to attract attention from historians and philosophers of art is the question of what role the audience’s desires played in enabling the deception.

The Emmaus painting confirmed several things that people in the Dutch art world of 1937 wanted to be true. They wanted a religious Vermeer — it filled a gap, confirmed a theory, and expanded the stature of one of the most beloved Dutch painters. They wanted a Dutch cultural triumph at a moment of increasing European tension — the painting was presented as a Dutch family’s possession, and its acquisition for a Dutch public collection was framed as keeping a masterpiece in its proper national home. They wanted Bredius to be right — his authority was institutional as much as individual, and challenging his judgment would have meant challenging the credibility of the entire connoisseurial establishment.

Jonathan Lopez, the British author who wrote a detailed account of the van Meegeren case, has argued that the specific visual character of the Emmaus figures — with their idealized, generalized, slightly Aryan-looking faces — was part of van Meegeren’s calculation. The aesthetic of idealized northern European physiognomy, he suggested, fit the visual culture of the late 1930s in ways that a more individually characterized Vermeer might not have. This argument is contested and was not part of van Meegeren’s own account of his choices. It represents one interpretive dimension of a complex case rather than an established fact.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.