A *Lady Playing a Lute* attributed to van Meegeren — one of his non-Vermeer period works — entered the Rijksmuseum and is documented there as part of the museum’s holdings related to the case. His forgeries, exposed and attributed, now exist in a category that the art market of 1937 could not have imagined: valuable precisely because of their forgery, documented evidence of a remarkable act of sustained deception, objects whose history is now more interesting than any genuine attribution could have made them.

—

## The Verdict of History

The Van Meegeren case has accumulated layers of interpretation that complicate any simple moral verdict.

The basic facts are clear: a skilled painter, motivated partly by resentment and partly by greed, spent years preparing forgeries and then spent years selling them to buyers who paid enormous sums for objects they believed to be seventeenth-century masterpieces. He deceived museums, private collectors, the art establishment, and the public. When he was caught, the specific chain of his capture — the wartime sale to Göring — allowed him to construct a narrative that cast his crime as a form of resistance. The Dutch public responded to that narrative with sympathy, to the point of near-celebrity.

The sympathy was not entirely misplaced. The critics who had dismissed him as derivative had been proven, in a narrow technical sense, wrong: he could produce a work convincing enough to fool the most respected expert in the field. His diagnosis of the connoisseurial establishment’s weaknesses — its reliance on authority, its susceptibility to confirmation of its own theories, its institutional resistance to challenge — was accurate. The *Supper at Emmaus* demonstrated all of these weaknesses in a single transaction.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.