But the sympathy ignored the specifics of the fraud. Van Meegeren did not simply prove a point. He took money — large amounts of money, from institutions and individuals — in exchange for objects he knew to be worthless in the terms they were sold. The buyers were deceived. The institutions that paid public funds for forgeries had their resources depleted and their collections compromised. The *Washing of the Feet* at the Rijksmuseum cost the institution approximately 1.3 million guilders in 1943 money. That money was lost. The painting it purchased was not what the institution needed.

His defense — that he forged to expose the critics, to prove his abilities, to resist the establishment — was undermined by the fact that he never carried out the original plan to reveal the fraud. After the Emmaus, he simply continued. The resentment that had motivated the original plan had been replaced by greed and by the pleasures of a lifestyle the forgeries funded. The artistic statement gave way to the business.

—

## Why a Convincing Attribution Persists

The van Meegeren case is sometimes offered as a simple cautionary tale about the limits of expert judgment. This is accurate but incomplete.

What the case actually illustrates is the specific social and institutional structure that makes expert judgment authoritative. Bredius’s authentication was not simply his personal opinion. It was an institutional act: the most respected scholar in the field had spoken, in print, in a prestigious journal, with his name and reputation attached. That act created a cascade of subsequent decisions — the acquisition, the scholarship, the citations — each of which added another layer of institutional authority to the attribution. By the time anyone might have had reason to doubt the Emmaus, it was not just Bredius’s reputation that would have needed to be overcome. It was the entire structure of authority that his authentication had initiated.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.