By 1937, Vermeer scholarship was both active and somewhat embattled. The catalogue of authenticated works had been refined over decades of connoisseurial argument. Attribution disputes — over works whose quality was debated or whose provenance was uncertain — were ongoing. The small size of the authenticated catalogue meant that scholars paid intense attention to anything that might expand it. And the theoretical frameworks that explained Vermeer’s development — including the Italian trip hypothesis — were actively debated rather than settled.
Bredius occupied a central position in this scholarly community. He had published extensively on Rembrandt, on Dutch Golden Age painting generally, and on Vermeer specifically. He had spent decades building the relationships and the reputation that made his pronouncements authoritative. He was, in 1937, at the end of his active scholarly life — he was eighty-three — and his record gave him every reason to trust his judgment about a painting that confirmed his existing theoretical framework.
The specific argument the Emmaus painting made within this framework was sophisticated. Van Meegeren had studied not just Vermeer’s authenticated works but the scholarly literature about them — the theoretical debates, the specific details that scholars had identified as characteristic, the unresolved questions about Vermeer’s development. He had read Bredius. He knew what Bredius would look for.
The *pointillés* — those small dabs of bright paint that appear on the bread, on the carafe, on specific surfaces in the composition — were a detail Bredius had specifically identified as characteristic of Vermeer in his earlier scholarship. When van Meegeren included them in the Emmaus, he was not simply imitating a stylistic feature he had noticed. He was including a marker that he knew Bredius had identified as specifically Vermeer’s, a visual signature that would read to Bredius as evidence of the master’s hand.
