—

## Reception Among the Experts: Resistance and Reconsideration

When van Meegeren confessed and claimed that the works in question were his own forgeries, the experts who had authenticated them did not immediately accept this claim. Their resistance was not simply professional self-protection, though self-protection was certainly part of it. The claim that van Meegeren had produced these works was, to them, technically implausible.

Bredius, by then very old and in poor health, was not in a position to respond substantively. He had authenticated the Emmaus in 1937 and his authority on the subject was absolute at the time. The question of his response to the exposure was complicated by his declining condition, and he died in 1946, before the trial that confirmed van Meegeren’s claims.

Other scholars were more actively resistant. D.G. van Beuningen, who had spent enormous sums acquiring works from the same network, refused to believe the works he had bought were forgeries and reportedly maintained this position long after the chemical analysis had established the anachronistic materials. His lawsuit against Paul Coremans after the publication of the investigation results represented a formal expression of this resistance — an attempt to discredit the forensic analysis by legal means.

The experts who had been involved in authenticating the works other than the Emmaus — the works that van Meegeren later claimed for himself — were similarly resistant. Their resistance rested partly on the genuine implausibility of the claim: a Dutch painter of moderate reputation, working in Nice, had produced forgeries convincing enough to fool the most respected authorities in the field across a decade of sales. The claim required accepting that the entire authentication network had failed repeatedly, that multiple experts had been wrong, that the institutional credibility of Dutch art expertise had been systematically exploited.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.