What van Meegeren changed, or accelerated, was the development of forensic art analysis as a standard component of the authentication process. His specific methods — the synthetic resin binder, the oven baking, the prepared craquelure — were designed to defeat the specific tests that authenticators applied. In defeating those tests, he also demonstrated their inadequacy, and the inadequacy of the broader authentication protocol that depended on them.
The subsequent development of pigment analysis, of X-ray radiography, of infrared reflectography, of dendrochronology for panel paintings, of lead-210 and other forms of isotopic dating, was not driven solely by the van Meegeren case. These methods were developed across a range of institutions and in response to a range of challenges. But the van Meegeren case — specifically the fact that a decade of sophisticated forgery had passed undetected through the most prestigious channels of the art market — created a specific institutional argument for changing the authentication protocol.
The argument was straightforward: if Abraham Bredius, with all his experience and all his authority, could be fooled by a forger who had studied his methods and his theoretical framework, then the connoisseur’s eye alone was not an adequate foundation for the authentication of major attributions. Physical and chemical evidence should be required, not optional. The anachronisms that van Meegeren’s forgeries contained — the Bakelite medium, the cobalt blue, the radium-depleted lead-210 — were there to be found by any examiner who looked for them. No one looked for them because no one expected to need to look.
After 1947, the expectation changed.
