—

## The Question of Artistic Merit

A dimension of the van Meegeren case that continues to attract attention is the question of what, if anything, the forgeries represent as works of art independent of their forgery status.

Van Meegeren was, as the evidence of his forgeries demonstrated, a painter of considerable technical skill. He had mastered the specific techniques of seventeenth-century Dutch painting at a level that allowed him to produce works convincing enough to fool the foremost experts in that field. He had studied the chemistry and physics of Old Master painting with a thoroughness that was, in a narrow sense, comparable to serious academic research. He had spent years refining his technique through practice and experimentation.

The forgeries, viewed as works of art rather than as crimes, are not simple copies of existing paintings. They are original compositions in Vermeer’s style — van Meegeren’s constructions of what a Vermeer might look like, based on deep knowledge of Vermeer’s authenticated works and of the scholarly framework around them. The *Supper at Emmaus* is not a copy of an existing Vermeer. It is a Vermeer that van Meegeren invented.

This creates an interesting evaluative question. The painting that Bredius praised as the masterpiece of Vermeer of Delft has not physically changed since 1937. The paint is the same paint. The composition is the same composition. The *pointillés* on the bread are the same *pointillés*. What changed, in 1945, was the attribution — the name in the label. And the attribution changed how people saw what was in front of them.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.