The critics who had praised the painting under the Vermeer attribution found, after the exposure, that they could no longer see the same qualities in it. The figures that had seemed to show the early development of a great master now seemed stilted and unconvincing. The qualities that had read as evidence of Vermeer’s hand now seemed like obvious markers of a forger’s imitation. The painting had not changed. The eyes looking at it had changed, because they were now looking at a van Meegeren rather than a Vermeer.
This perceptual shift — the way attribution shapes aesthetic response — is one of the most discussed aspects of the van Meegeren case in the philosophy of art. The case raises genuine questions about whether the aesthetic value of a work of art is entirely intrinsic to the physical object, or whether it is constituted, in part, by the context of creation — the period, the artist, the cultural position of the work in its historical moment.
Van Meegeren’s own comment on this question — his reported statement that “my triumph as a counterfeiter was my defeat as a creative artist” — is often cited as evidence of his awareness of the paradox. He had produced work that the most respected experts in the field called a masterpiece. But they had called it a masterpiece because they believed it was a Vermeer. As a van Meegeren, it was not a masterpiece to anyone. The achievement and the defeat were the same event.
—
## The Victims and What Was Lost
