—

## The Gap Between Technical Achievement and Artistic Value

Van Meegeren’s case forces a distinction that is often glossed over in popular accounts of art forgery: the difference between technical skill and artistic achievement.

He was, unquestionably, technically skilled. The evidence of that skill is irrefutable — the forgeries passed the scrutiny of experts who had spent careers studying the specific painter van Meegeren was imitating. He had mastered the material processes of seventeenth-century painting: the preparation of pigments, the construction of canvas, the application of paint in layers, the management of light and shadow in a tradition that had specific, identifiable conventions. He had gone beyond mastery of the visual to mastery of the physical — understanding the chemistry of aging paint, the physics of craquelure, the specific tests that experts applied and how to defeat them.

But technical skill, however impressive, is not the same as artistic achievement. The painters of the Dutch Golden Age whom van Meegeren imitated were valued not simply for their technical accomplishment — though that was part of their achievement — but for the specific quality of perception and expression that their technical skill served. Vermeer’s domestic interiors are not simply demonstrations of how to render light on a white wall or how to apply *pointillés* to a loaf of bread. They are expressions of a specific way of seeing, a specific relationship to the people and objects they depict. That quality — the thing that makes a great Vermeer a Vermeer rather than simply a technically accomplished seventeenth-century Dutch interior — is not something van Meegeren was trying to replicate, because it is not something that can be directly imitated.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.