What he replicated was the surface vocabulary — the visual marks and conventions that experts had identified as characteristic of Vermeer’s hand. He replicated the signs of the achievement rather than the achievement itself. And the signs were convincing enough to be mistaken for the thing they signified, at least when the thing doing the signifying was a physical painting presented in a context that made its fraudulent origin invisible.
This is why the revelation of the forgery changes how the paintings look to experienced viewers. The qualities that read as evidence of Vermeer’s specific way of seeing, when the painting is believed to be a Vermeer, read as evidence of technical competence deployed in service of imitation when the painting is known to be a van Meegeren. The same visual marks carry different meaning depending on what is known about their origin.
Van Meegeren was aware of this paradox, or came to be aware of it. His remark about triumph as a counterfeiter being defeat as a creative artist indicates an understanding that his success had consumed the very thing he claimed to be vindicating. He had proved that he could produce signs of mastery convincing enough to fool the masters’ greatest experts. He had not proved, and could not prove, that he possessed the mastery itself.
—
## The Structure of the Art Market and Its Vulnerabilities
The van Meegeren case is not only a story about individual expertise and its limits. It is also a story about the structure of the art market and the specific vulnerabilities that structure creates.
