The lesson is about protocols, not about the inherent superiority of one mode of analysis over another. Visual assessment by trained experts is a valuable and irreplaceable part of the authentication toolkit. It identifies characteristics and details that physical and chemical analysis cannot access. But it is not adequate, by itself, for a problem that includes sophisticated forgers who know what it is designed to detect and how to defeat it. The combination of expert visual assessment and routine physical and chemical analysis is more robust than either alone — and it was the absence of that combination, rather than the failure of expert visual assessment as such, that van Meegeren exploited.

—

## The Specific Legacy in Dutch Cultural History

The van Meegeren case has a specific place in Dutch cultural history that goes beyond its significance as a case study in art forgery or authentication.

The Netherlands in 1945 was a country that had endured five years of German occupation — years that had involved the deportation and murder of the majority of its Jewish community, the looting of cultural and material property on a massive scale, and the profound disruptions of a society operating under occupation and collaborating or resisting in various ways. The moral reckoning with that experience was a central preoccupation of Dutch public life in the immediate postwar period.

Van Meegeren’s story inserted itself into this reckoning in a specific way. He had operated throughout the occupation, selling works to German buyers and to Dutch buyers, accumulating wealth while the occupation continued. He had, in that sense, been a participant in the wartime economy rather than a victim of or a resister to the occupation. The specific story of the Göring transaction allowed him to construct a narrative that cast his participation in a more favorable light — but that narrative depended on eliding the broader pattern of his wartime sales.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.