The moral complexity of the wartime Dutch art market — the range of motivations, from opportunism to genuine resistance, with every gradation in between — is part of the context in which the van Meegeren case must be understood. His postwar self-presentation as a heroic resistance figure who had tricked the Nazis was at the simplistic end of that range. His actual conduct during the occupation was that of a man who used the wartime disruption to continue and expand a business of fraud, targeting buyers with money regardless of where that money came from.
—
## The Coremans Report as a Methodological Landmark
Paul Coremans’s investigation of the van Meegeren forgeries produced not just the evidence that confirmed van Meegeren’s confession but a methodological model for how forensic analysis should be conducted in attribution disputes.
His approach combined multiple independent lines of evidence. He did not rely on any single test or any single type of evidence. Instead, he assembled a converging case: the X-ray evidence that showed original paintings beneath the surface; the chemical analysis that found synthetic resins in the paint; the pigment analysis that identified anachronistic materials; the physical evidence of the canvas; the comparison of materials found in van Meegeren’s studio with materials found in the contested works.
Each line of evidence was, in principle, independently falsifiable. If the X-rays had shown no original paintings beneath the surface, that would have undermined one aspect of the case. If the chemical analysis had found only seventeenth-century compatible materials, that would have undermined another. If van Meegeren’s studio had not contained the materials found in the paint of the contested works, that would have weakened the connection between the man and the objects.
