The fact that all of these independent lines of evidence converged on the same conclusion — that the works were modern, that they contained twentieth-century materials, that van Meegeren had the means and the materials to have produced them — was what made the case compelling beyond reasonable doubt.
Coremans published his findings in a formal report that became a methodological reference for subsequent forensic art investigation. The specific tests he applied — the chemical analysis of binding media, the pigment analysis for anachronistic materials, the X-ray radiography, the canvas analysis — became standard components of authentication investigations for major attributions. His report established what a thorough forensic investigation should look like, and the subsequent development of forensic art analysis built on the methodological foundation he had laid.
The specific analytical techniques have evolved substantially since 1947. Gas chromatography, mass spectrometry, neutron activation analysis, and other methods have been added to the toolkit. The sensitivity and specificity of pigment analysis have improved dramatically. Dendrochronology has enabled precise dating of wooden panel paintings. Lead-210 and other isotopic techniques have been refined. But the methodological principle — that attribution disputes should be resolved by multiple convergent lines of physical evidence rather than by the authority of individual experts — was established, in substantial part, by the Coremans investigation of the van Meegeren forgeries.
—
## Continuing Significance: What the Case Teaches About How We Know What We Know
Decades after van Meegeren’s death, his case continues to be discussed not only in the specialized literature of art authentication but in broader discussions of how knowledge is established, validated, and sometimes overturned.
