The case sits at the intersection of several questions that extend well beyond the art world. How do institutions establish credibility? What happens when credibility is used as a shield against scrutiny rather than a product of scrutiny? How does the structure of authority in a field determine what kinds of errors are possible and what kinds of corrections are thinkable?

In 1937, the structure of authority in Vermeer scholarship made Bredius’s authentication effectively unquestionable. His word was the final word, not because he was infallible but because the institutional structure of the field concentrated authority in a small number of recognized experts and provided no mechanism for routinely subjecting their judgments to independent technical verification. That structure was not irrational. It was an efficient response to the genuine complexity of the subject matter. But it was also a structure that a sophisticated forger who understood it could exploit, by targeting the right expert and producing the right painting.

The reform of that structure — the institutionalization of technical analysis as a standard component of authentication — was a rational response to the exposure of its vulnerability. But the reform also illustrates a general point about how institutions change: they tend to respond to the specific failure that has been exposed rather than to the class of failures of which the specific case is an example. The measures that were implemented after the van Meegeren case addressed the specific techniques he had used — the synthetic resins, the oven baking — rather than the broader question of how sophisticated forgery could defeat any specific set of tests that were known in advance.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.