Subsequent forgery cases have demonstrated that this is a genuine limitation. When forgers understand the tests that authenticators apply, they construct their forgeries to pass those tests. The specific methods change as the tests change. The cat-and-mouse dynamic between forgers and authenticators is not, in principle, resolvable by any finite set of technical tests, because the set of possible forgery methods is not finite.
The more robust response is methodological diversity — the use of multiple independent lines of evidence, with no single test regarded as sufficient by itself, and the assumption that any method known to forgers is a method that sophisticated forgers will prepare for. This is the methodological principle that Coremans’s investigation demonstrated, and it remains the most defensible approach to authentication in a field where the possibility of sophisticated forgery must always be assumed.
—
## Final Reflection: The Painting That Is Exactly What It Appears to Be
There is a specific irony embedded in the final disposition of the *Supper at Emmaus*.
When the painting hung in the Boijmans as a Vermeer, it was not what it appeared to be. It appeared to be a seventeenth-century masterpiece by one of the greatest painters of the Dutch Golden Age. It was, in fact, a twentieth-century forgery by a Dutch portraitist who had spent six years preparing to create it in a villa in the south of France.
Now that the painting hangs — when it hangs — in the Boijmans as a van Meegeren, it is exactly what it appears to be. It is a highly skilled forgery by Han van Meegeren, painted in Vermeer’s style, using techniques designed to defeat the authentication procedures of its era, presented to the most authoritative Vermeer expert alive and authenticated by him as a masterpiece. The label is correct. The provenance is documented. The materials have been analyzed. The history has been established.
