He made several practice works that he decided were not good enough to pass. He refined his technique until he was confident. And then, in 1936, he began the painting that would become the centerpiece of the most successful art forgery in the twentieth century.
—
## Painting the Masterpiece
The *Supper at Emmaus* was painted at van Meegeren’s villa in Roquebrune in 1936. He took an authentic seventeenth-century canvas, cleared the original painting from it, and built up his composition using the materials and methods he had spent years developing.
The composition itself was his own invention in Vermeer’s style — not a copy of any specific work but a construction from the vocabulary he had identified as Vermeer’s: the figures placed in a shallow space, the light source controlled and directional, the palette restrained and specific, the textures carefully differentiated. He included the details he had identified as the most compelling markers of Vermeer’s hand — the *pointillés* on the bread crust that Bredius would specifically note in his Burlington Magazine article, the carafe that appeared in only a small number of authenticated Vermeer works, the colors that Bredius would recognize.
The figures were, to some later eyes, slightly stilted — the faces more generalized than Vermeer’s characteristically individualized subjects. But in the context of a proposed early religious work, painted before Vermeer found his mature style, this quality could be read as evidence of development rather than deficiency. Van Meegeren was not accidentally producing a mediocre Vermeer. He was deliberately producing what an early Vermeer might look like before the refinements of the domestic period.
