This omission was not accidental. It reflected editorial decisions about whose contributions were worth reporting, filtered through the racial assumptions of the era’s journalism. Black Americans and their achievements were systematically underreported in mainstream white newspapers of this period; the Black press — newspapers like the Chicago Defender, the Pittsburgh Courier, and the Cleveland Call (which Morgan himself would found in 1920) — existed in part to fill the coverage gaps that mainstream papers left.

 

The 1920 founding of the Cleveland Call, four years after the tunnel disaster, was partly Morgan’s response to this coverage problem. A newspaper he owned and controlled could not exclude his name from its own stories. The Cleveland Call reported on the African American community of Cleveland — its businesses, its civic organizations, its legal and political challenges, its achievements — in ways that the mainstream Cleveland press did not.

 

The irony that one of the tunnel disaster’s principal figures founded a newspaper because the existing newspapers had erased him from their coverage is not stated in accessible sources; it is an inference from the available facts. But it is a reasonable inference, and it places the newspaper in a larger context than simple business entrepreneurship.

 

The newspapers that covered the disaster without Morgan’s name were doing what newspapers do: reflecting the values and assumptions of the society they served, filtered through the specific judgments of editors and reporters who were themselves products of that society. The editors who decided not to include Morgan’s name did not necessarily sit down and reason explicitly about their racial assumptions; the assumption of Black non-relevance to important civic events was sufficiently embedded in the journalism of the period to operate without explicit reasoning.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.