## Whittlesey and the Weight of Survival

 

The arc of Whittlesey’s postwar life is one of the most striking elements of the Lost Battalion’s aftermath, and it illuminates something important about the cost of the story’s public construction.

 

Whittlesey returned to New York after the war and tried to resume his law practice. He was a changed man by the accounts of those who knew him. The deaths of the men under his command — the 107 confirmed dead, the 150 or more who were missing or captured, the wounded who would carry the marks of the Argonne for the rest of their lives — were not abstract figures to him. He had been there. He had known the men individually. He had issued the orders that placed them in the positions where they were killed.

 

The celebrity that the Lost Battalion story brought him was something he had not sought and could not easily escape. He became a public figure who was asked, repeatedly, to speak about the events in the Argonne, to represent the battalion at public ceremonies, to embody the narrative that the story had constructed. He was invited to dinners, asked to give speeches, presented at events where he was expected to perform the role of the hero.

 

His escorting of the Unknown Soldier’s remains in 1921 put him in the center of a national ceremony of grief and remembrance. The Unknown Soldier was, in a sense, a placeholder for all the American dead of the war — for the men like those under Whittlesey’s command whose deaths had not been fully accounted for. Standing at the center of that ceremony, months before he disappeared, Whittlesey was in a position that required him to be simultaneously the survivor and the representative of the dead.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.