Richards was doing a job that the Signal Corps had trained him to do. He knew the pigeons individually — had fed them, cared for them, transported them into the forest, and managed their allocation across days of fighting. The decision to hold Cher Ami until the moment of maximum need was his professional judgment. The decision to climb the tree and force the reluctant bird into flight was his improvisation under fire.

 

The specific choice to climb the tree and shake the branch to get the bird airborne is one of the more vivid details of the story, and it appears in multiple accounts. It is the kind of detail that the people present would remember — the handler climbing a tree under shelling to dislodge a pigeon that had decided this was not a good moment to fly. Whether Richards or someone else present climbed the tree, and exactly how the bird was persuaded to launch, may vary slightly in different accounts. But the general substance — that the bird initially refused to fly and had to be encouraged by human intervention — is consistent across sources.

 

## The Aerial Supply Missions and Their Failure

 

The aerial resupply missions flown by the 50th Aero Squadron on October 5 and 6 are worth examining in detail, because they represent the other major technological attempt to reach the Lost Battalion and illustrate the limits of the available options.

 

The October 5 missions were described as the first American aerial supply operation. Aircraft dropped food and ammunition from low altitude in an attempt to place supplies within the battalion’s perimeter. The problem was precision. Aircraft in 1918 could fly over a position, but dropping supplies accurately enough to land within a small defensive perimeter in dense forest was extremely difficult. Most of the supplies missed. Some fell into German-held territory. The battalion received little benefit from the first day’s missions.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.