October 6 brought more missions and a different objective. Pilots Goettler and Bleckley were specifically tasked with locating the battalion’s exact position — a reconnaissance mission to identify where the men actually were, so that subsequent supply or artillery support could be accurately aimed. They flew at low altitude to get a clear view of the forest below them. At that altitude, they were vulnerable to ground fire, and they were shot down. Both men died. Their contribution was the map they were carrying, which French ground forces later found and which helped confirm the battalion’s position.
The aerial supply failures and the deaths of Goettler and Bleckley illustrate the gap between the promise of new technology and its actual performance under combat conditions. Aviation was new enough in 1918 that the possibility of aerial supply seemed genuinely promising. The reality was that the technology was not yet precise enough to deliver supplies to a small position in difficult terrain from aircraft that had to maintain altitude to avoid ground fire.
The comparison with Cher Ami’s flight is instructive. The pigeon did something the aircraft could not: it delivered a specific message, accurately, to a specific location, without the kind of precision that the aircraft could not achieve. The pigeon was not a superior technology in general terms — aircraft would eventually make pigeon communications obsolete. But in the specific conditions of October 1918, it did something aircraft could not.
## The October 7 Surrender Demand
On October 7, 1918, a German officer delivered to Whittlesey a formal surrender demand. The document, written in English, noted the hopelessness of the battalion’s position and offered honorable terms of surrender.
