Whittlesey did not respond. His report stated simply: “No reply to the demand to surrender seemed necessary.” McMurtry’s contemporaneous comment, as reported in various accounts, was to the effect that the Germans were more worried than the Americans — an observation that may have been accurate, since the German withdrawal later that same day suggests the German position was under its own pressure.

 

The surrender demand has become one of the more quotable elements of the Lost Battalion story, partly because Whittlesey’s non-response has an elegance to it that formal responses rarely achieve. He did not write a defiant reply. He did not send back an insulting counter-message. He did not acknowledge the demand at all. His report’s explanation — “no reply seemed necessary” — is the kind of understatement that becomes legendary precisely because it refuses the dramatic gesture that the moment might seem to call for.

 

The surrender demand also documents something important about the German position. By October 7, the Germans had been trying to destroy or capture the surrounded American force for five days. They had used conventional infantry attacks, artillery, flamethrowers, and diplomatic persuasion. None had succeeded. The surrender demand was the final attempt before the German withdrawal, and its failure confirmed that the battalion was not going to break.

 

The German withdrawal that evening was not the result of any action by the battalion itself. It was the result of the broader American advance in the Argonne, which was compressing German positions from multiple directions. Whittlesey’s men had not driven the Germans away. The Germans had left because continuing to hold the position was no longer consistent with their overall tactical situation.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.