This position had two critical vulnerabilities. First, it was a dead end: the battalion had advanced into the valley but could not advance further without clearing the high ground, and the high ground was now held by German forces. Second, it was visible from above: German observers on the surrounding ridgelines could see the American position and direct fire onto it with precision. The friendly fire barrage on October 4 was partly the result of this visibility — American artillery observers who did not know exactly where the battalion was may have been directing fire based on the best information available, which was wrong.

 

The forest itself added to the difficulty. Shell bursts in trees created airbursts that sent shrapnel in all directions, amplifying the danger of artillery fire. Men who might have survived a burst on open ground were exposed to a much larger danger zone in forest. The dense vegetation also made it difficult for the relief forces to find the exact position of the battalion, which is why the aerial reconnaissance missions on October 6 were specifically aimed at locating the precise location rather than simply approaching the general area.

 

## The Experience of Encirclement

 

Five days of encirclement in the Argonne Forest is a human experience that the historical record documents in outline but cannot fully reconstruct. The survivors’ accounts, filtered through the passage of time and the requirements of official reporting, give a picture that is incomplete by its nature.

 

The physical conditions were severe. By October 4, the men had been without resupply for two days. They had consumed whatever food they had carried in. Water was not available from any reliable source. The wounded required care with no medical supplies beyond what the unit had carried, and the volume of wounded was increasing every day. The dead were accumulating in a position too small to easily manage them.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.