The American Battle Monuments Commission and the National Archives hold records related to the Meuse-Argonne offensive that researchers interested in the broader context of the Lost Battalion’s situation can consult. The 77th Division’s official history, published in the immediate aftermath of the war, is a primary document for the events of September and October 1918.

 

Future research may resolve some of the remaining uncertainties — the specific question of when Cher Ami was wounded, for example, or the exact timeline of the artillery correction on October 4. Or it may not. Some historical questions cannot be resolved from the surviving record, and honesty about that uncertainty is itself a form of historical accuracy.

 

 

## The Hundred-Year Display

 

The Smithsonian’s decision to display Cher Ami continuously since 1921 reflects an institutional commitment that is worth examining in its own right. Museums make decisions about what to display and what to store, what to highlight and what to contextualize, and those decisions are themselves historical acts.

 

The hundred-year display of Cher Ami represents a decision that this object, and the story attached to it, has continuing public value. That judgment has been periodically renewed by the generations of Smithsonian curators who have maintained the exhibit, and it is reflected in the placement of the bird in the flagship military history exhibition rather than in storage or in a minor gallery.

 

The decision to maintain the display through the 2021 reassessment — rather than removing the bird or dramatically de-emphasizing the story — reflects a view that the complicated version of the story is worth telling and that the physical object provides a valuable anchor for it. A story about military legend-making, about the gap between events and their commemoration, about the role of institutions in shaping historical memory, is not a lesser story than a straightforward heroism narrative. It is a richer one.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.