On the evening of July 28, 1996, two young men wading in the shallows of the Columbia River near Kennewick, Washington, spotted something lodged in the bank. It was a human skull. By the time an anthropologist named James Chatters arrived on the scene, the skull had already passed through the hands of a county coroner who wanted to know whether he was looking at a recent homicide. Within weeks, Chatters would describe the skull’s features in terms that set off a nearly twenty-year legal and scientific battle. Within two decades, those same bones would be at the center of a question that reached into the deepest layers of American history: who had the right to claim them, to study them, and to lay them to rest?

—

## The Discovery at Columbia Park

The Columbia River runs for more than 1,200 miles through the Pacific Northwest. Near Kennewick, Washington, in the southeastern corner of the state, it passes through a broad, dry landscape of basalt cliffs and sagebrush. The land along the river’s banks in that stretch is managed by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, a federal agency whose primary mission is infrastructure and waterway management, but whose jurisdiction over the land would become central to the events that followed.

Will Thomas and Dave Deacy were spectators at the local hydroplane races on the evening of July 28, 1996. While wading in the river near Columbia Park, they found what appeared to be a human skull. They brought it to the attention of local authorities. The Benton County Sheriff’s office called the county coroner, Floyd Johnson. Johnson, in turn, called his friend James Chatters.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.