The residents who remained at Kalaupapa in the late twentieth century — some voluntarily, having nowhere else to go after decades of confinement, some by their own choice to remain in a community that had become their home — were increasingly elderly. The settlement became a National Historical Park in 1980, administered by the National Park Service in cooperation with the Hawaii Department of Health and the residents. By the 1990s and 2000s, it had become a place that told its own history to the visitors who came by limited access tours.

 

The survivors and their descendants have been central to the effort to tell Kalaupapa’s history accurately — including the parts of that history that resist simplification. The settlement is not simply a story of medical heroism, though the physicians and caregivers who worked there included genuinely dedicated people. It is a story of a government policy of mandatory exile enforced against a predominantly indigenous population for more than a century, motivated in part by racial anxieties and in part by genuine (if excessive and misapplied) public health concerns, and maintained long after any legitimate public health rationale had expired.

 

Alice Ball’s work fits into this larger Kalaupapa story not as a simple triumph but as a complicated intervention. Her injectable preparation helped some patients recover and return home — a genuine and important outcome. It was produced and deployed in a system that continued to confine other patients involuntarily throughout the period of its use. The treatment improved individual outcomes without changing the institutional framework that had produced those outcomes in the first place. That framing does not diminish what Ball did; it contextualizes it accurately within the history that surrounded it.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.