Because NAGPRA did not apply — based on this ruling — the remains were subject instead to the Archaeological Resources Protection Act. That law allowed scientific study of archaeological materials on federal land. The scientists had the right to study them.
The Interior Department and the five tribes appealed. In February 2004, the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit upheld Jelderks’ ruling. The court found that the tribal claims had not met the standard of proof that NAGPRA required. In July 2004, the tribes and the federal government chose not to appeal to the Supreme Court.
Scientific study of the remains could proceed.
—
## What the Scientists Found: Morphology and Its Limits
The plaintiff scientists conducted their examinations in several stages, with visits to the Burke Museum between December 2004 and February 2006. Their findings were eventually compiled into a comprehensive volume published in 2014: *Kennewick Man: The Scientific Investigation of an Ancient American Skeleton*, edited by Douglas Owsley and Richard Jantz.
The morphological analysis — the study of the bones’ physical shape — was extensive. Owsley’s team at the Smithsonian was particularly focused on what the skull and skeleton could tell them about population affinity. Their conclusion, based on comparisons with skeletal reference collections from populations around the world, was that Kennewick Man’s skull most closely resembled those of Pacific Rim peoples — specifically the Ainu of Japan and Polynesian populations — rather than modern Native Americans.
The Ainu are the indigenous people of Hokkaido and surrounding islands in Japan, with a distinct history and appearance from the majority Japanese population. Polynesians are the peoples of the Pacific islands, including New Zealand, Hawaii, and Samoa. The morphological resemblance to these populations, the scientists argued, was consistent with the hypothesis that Kennewick Man represented an early population that was distinct from the ancestors of most present-day Native Americans.
