The five tribes, the federal government, and the plaintiff scientists had no interest in the Asatru claim and did not treat it as a serious legal complication. It passed through the proceedings and left no legal mark on the outcome.
—
## The DNA Era: Why Earlier Attempts Failed
The irony of the Kennewick Man case is that DNA evidence — which ultimately resolved the central scientific and legal questions — was not available for most of the legal proceedings. This was not for lack of trying.
Earlier attempts to extract ancient DNA from the remains had failed. The bones’ exterior was well preserved, but the DNA inside them had degraded to the point where earlier extraction methods could not recover reliable sequences. Ancient DNA is inherently fragile. DNA molecules break down over time through chemical processes — hydrolysis and oxidation, primarily — leaving shorter and shorter fragments. Contamination with environmental DNA, including from bacteria in the soil, adds further complexity: distinguishing authentic ancient human DNA from bacterial DNA requires careful technique and rigorous controls.
The techniques available for ancient DNA analysis in the late 1990s and early 2000s were not equal to the challenge that Kennewick Man’s remains presented. The bones looked well preserved from the outside, but the genetic material inside was extensively damaged. As Morten Rasmussen later described it, the sample was “highly degraded” despite the skeleton’s pristine exterior.
The resolution of this problem came from advances in ancient DNA methodology developed primarily during the 2000s and 2010s. New techniques could work with much shorter DNA fragments, could better distinguish endogenous human DNA from environmental contamination, and could reconstruct genomes from highly degraded material. These advances transformed ancient DNA research. What had been impossible in 1996 became possible by 2015.
