Owsley was forthright about his position in public statements. He said the decision on repatriation should ultimately be made by the courts, and that the DNA evidence, while significant, did not on its own resolve the legal question as NAGPRA’s courts had framed it.
—
## Congress Acts: December 2016
The legal route — another round of federal litigation — was preempted by Congress.
In December 2016, Congress passed and President Barack Obama signed the Water Resources Development Act. Embedded in that legislation was a provision specifically addressing the Kennewick remains: it directed the Army Corps of Engineers to repatriate the Ancient One to the five claimant tribes within 90 days.
This was a legislative solution to a legal impasse. Rather than allowing the litigation to continue through the federal courts — a process that could take years and produce another ruling on the technical question of whether the DNA evidence satisfied NAGPRA’s affiliation standard — Congress simply directed the transfer. The legislative provision essentially superseded the question of whether the DNA evidence met the legal standard by requiring repatriation regardless of that determination.
The provision was notable because it named the Ancient One specifically, which was unusual in legislation of this type. It was also notable because it resolved a case that had been disputed in federal courts for two decades through a legislative mechanism rather than a judicial one.
For the five tribes, the legislation was vindication after twenty years of legal struggle. For some of the plaintiff scientists, it was a frustrating end to a process that they felt had been resolved against them through political rather than legal means.
