The nature of that collaboration deserves recognition. For the Colville to contribute DNA to a study of a contested ancestral individual required a form of trust — trust that the researchers would handle the data responsibly, attribute findings correctly, and respect the tribal context of what they were doing. That the five-way coalition of tribes was not fully represented in the genomic data was not the fault of the researchers, who actively sought participation.
—
## The Kennewick Case and the Broader History of NAGPRA
The Kennewick Man case became, over time, the most prominent example of NAGPRA’s limits and of the tensions built into the law.
NAGPRA was enacted in 1990 after decades of advocacy. It represented a genuine shift in federal policy toward Native American ancestral remains and cultural property. Before NAGPRA, the standard treatment of Native American skeletal remains by federal agencies and research institutions was to treat them as scientific specimens, to be studied and stored. NAGPRA imposed a different framework: Native American remains belonged to Native American communities, and those communities had the right to reclaim them.
The law has had substantial effects. By some estimates, more than 50,000 sets of human remains, more than 1.4 million funerary objects, and thousands of sacred and communally owned objects had been repatriated under NAGPRA in its first two decades of operation. The law changed the relationship between research institutions and tribal communities in ways that persist.
But the Kennewick case exposed a gap in NAGPRA’s design: it did not clearly address how to handle remains so old that the standard framework for establishing cultural affiliation — documented historical connections, linguistic or cultural continuities — could not easily be applied. The gap was not an oversight so much as a reflection of the difficulty of legislating about deep prehistory. No one in 1990 fully anticipated that a nearly complete skeleton more than 9,000 years old would be found in circumstances that placed it squarely within the law’s scope.
