The Colville’s decision to contribute DNA to the 2015 study was not an endorsement of that framework. It was a pragmatic choice, made in the context of a legal and political struggle where the evidence produced by the study might make a difference in the outcome. The fact that the study ultimately supported their position does not mean they agreed that genetic testing was the appropriate way to decide the question.

Bustamante, one of the Stanford researchers who contributed to the 2015 paper, made a broader point: he said that ancient DNA analysis might become “standard practice” in cases involving NAGPRA claims. If that happened, it would change the evidentiary landscape in ways that might benefit tribes in some cases — as it had in the Kennewick case — but that would also institutionalize the idea that genetic proof was required to establish ancestral connection. This was a prospect that many tribal advocates viewed with concern.

—

## The Significance of the Cascades Projectile Point

Lost in the broader narrative of legal and scientific conflict is a detail that tells its own story: the Cascade projectile point embedded in Kennewick Man’s hip.

A Cascade point is a specific type of stone tool, leaf-shaped and serrated, produced by the peoples of the Pacific Northwest roughly 4,500 to 9,000 years ago. The point in Kennewick Man’s pelvis was not an artifact stored with his remains — it was embedded in his bone. He had been struck by a projectile point at some point during his life. The point remained in him. Bone grew around it. He healed and went on living.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.