In indigenous rights more broadly, the case was a reminder that legal processes designed to protect Native American rights could also be weaponized against them. The same NAGPRA that was meant to return ancestral remains to tribes was used, through litigation, to prevent that return for two decades. The lesson was not that NAGPRA was bad law, but that good law requires ongoing attention to prevent it from being used in ways that contradict its purpose.
—
## The Science of Early American Migration
The Kennewick case unfolded during a period of significant scientific debate about how and when the Americas were first populated.
The traditional model, dominant for much of the twentieth century, held that the Americas were populated by a single migration from northeast Asia across the Bering land bridge approximately 13,000 years ago. The migrants were the ancestors of all present-day Native Americans. Linguistic, genetic, and archaeological evidence all broadly supported this framework.
The discovery of sites that appeared to predate 13,000 years — Monte Verde in Chile, with dates around 14,500 years; possible sites even older in Brazil and elsewhere — created pressure on the single-migration model. If humans were in South America 14,500 years ago, they had to have entered North America even earlier, and perhaps by routes other than a single traversal of the Bering land bridge at a specific moment.
One hypothesis that gained traction in the 1990s was the “Paleoamerican” model: that there had been earlier migrations, perhaps of people with physical features different from those of the later migrants who became the ancestors of most present-day Native Americans. The skull of Kennewick Man, with its apparent resemblance to Pacific Rim populations, seemed to some scientists like potential evidence for this model — an early American with ancestry tracing to a coastal Asian population that had migrated along the Pacific rim before the main continental crossing.
