The Colville’s participation also carried risks. If the genomic comparison had not shown a close relationship — if the Ancient One’s genome had clustered with Polynesian or East Asian populations, as the morphological hypothesis suggested — that result might have been used in the litigation to argue against repatriation. By contributing their DNA, the Colville accepted the possibility of an adverse finding.

That the finding was not adverse — that the comparison placed Kennewick Man genetically closer to the Colville than to any other population that had been sequenced — was both a scientific result and a political one. It strengthened the tribes’ hand without definitively settling the NAGPRA question, but it shifted the momentum of the case.

—

## Repatriation as Restoration

Chip Colwell, an anthropologist and advocate who has written extensively on NAGPRA and on the ethics of handling indigenous cultural property, used the Kennewick case as an example in his analysis of what repatriation means and why it matters.

His argument was that repatriation is not simply about the disposition of objects — or remains. It is about the relationship between institutions and communities, and about whether that relationship is built on extraction or on respect. For generations, scientific and governmental institutions had treated Native American remains as raw material for research, as specimens to be studied and stored. NAGPRA was an attempt to rebalance that relationship. The Kennewick case was a test of whether the rebalancing would hold.

That it held — that the Ancient One was returned, after twenty years, to the five tribes who had claimed him — was not a foregone conclusion. It required two decades of litigation, an intervening DNA study that shifted the evidentiary picture, and ultimately a legislative intervention. But it happened.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.