The five tribes of the Columbia Plateau — the Confederated Tribes of the Umatilla Indian Reservation, the Yakama Nation, the Nez Perce Tribe, the Colville Confederated Tribes, and the Wanapum Band — understood the situation through a different framework. For them, the man found in the river was an ancestor. Their oral histories placed their people on the Columbia Plateau for thousands of years. The idea that scientific examination could override that ancestral connection — and the idea that the skull’s features might be used to argue the remains were not Native American — was both scientifically contested and deeply offensive.

Armand Minthorn, an Umatilla religious leader and board of trustees member, contacted the Army Corps of Engineers and asked that the remains be protected from further examination. The Yakama Nation made a similar request. The Corps, as the manager of the federal land where the remains had been found, took custody of the bones. Under the Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act — NAGPRA — enacted by Congress in 1990, federal agencies are required to determine whether human remains found on federal lands are Native American, and if so, to work with affiliated tribes on their disposition.

The Corps applied NAGPRA based on the remains’ age — over 9,000 years — and their location on what had historically been Umatilla traditional territory. On September 17, 1996, the Corps published a notice of intent to repatriate the remains to the five tribes.

—

## NAGPRA and What It Required

Before understanding the legal battle that followed, it helps to understand what NAGPRA actually required — and what it left ambiguous.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.