The broader question of how research institutions and Native American communities should relate to one another — how the genuine scientific value of studying ancient remains can be pursued in ways that respect the rights and interests of the communities from which those remains come — is a question that the Kennewick case made more visible without fully answering.

—

## Conclusion: What the DNA Actually Settled

The headline attached to the 2015 DNA study was “Mystery Solved: 8,500-Year-Old Kennewick Man Is a Native American After All.” That headline captured the most consequential aspect of the finding — that the genomic evidence contradicted the morphological hypothesis and placed the Ancient One firmly within the Native American ancestral population.

But the word “settled” requires some care.

The DNA settled the specific scientific question of Kennewick Man’s genomic affinity: he was more closely related to modern Native Americans than to any other population worldwide. His skull’s resemblance to Pacific Rim populations was not, in the genomic data, a signal of distinct ancestry — it was, as Willerslev had argued, an example of the large within-population variation in human skull morphology, combined with the methodological limitations of making population inferences from a single specimen.

The DNA did not settle the question of which specific tribe had the strongest claim to him. The researchers were explicit: with limited comparative data from Native American populations, they could not determine which group was closest. The Colville were the closest known relative, but that finding was contingent on the specific set of populations that had been sampled.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.