This argument had genuine force. The scientific value of studying ancient remains is real. The questions they can answer — about diet, mobility, health, population structure — cannot be answered from any other source. The plaintiff scientists were not wrong that Kennewick Man was scientifically important.

What they were wrong about — or at least what the evidence ultimately refuted — was the implied corollary: that the scientific importance of the remains was greater than, or at least equal to, the tribal claims on them. That judgment was not purely scientific. It was a judgment about whose interests mattered most, and it was a judgment that the legal proceedings, the legislative action, and ultimately history did not ratify.

—

## The Morphological Methods: A Closer Examination

To understand why the morphological findings seemed so compelling at the time — and why their refutation by DNA evidence was significant — it helps to look more closely at how morphological population affinity analysis actually works.

Physical anthropologists studying population affinity from skeletal remains use a method called craniometrics: the precise measurement of dimensions of the skull and facial bones. These measurements — distances between landmarks, angles between planes, proportions of different features — are assembled into a numerical profile for the specimen in question. That profile is then compared against reference databases compiled from populations whose ancestry is known.

The comparison is statistical. It asks: given the distribution of measurements in each reference population, what is the probability that this specimen belongs to each population? The result is not a categorical assignment — “this individual is Native American” — but a probability ranking: “this individual’s measurements fall closest to population X, with population Y and Z as next-closest matches.”

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.