Applied to remains from a few hundred or a few thousand years ago, with well-documented historical connections between specific tribes and specific archaeological sites, the law worked reasonably well. Applied to remains from 9,000 years ago, before the formation of any present tribal structure, it encountered genuine difficulties that its drafters had not fully anticipated.

—

## Friends of America’s Past

One of the institutional responses to the Kennewick case was the formation of Friends of America’s Past (FOAP), a Portland, Oregon-based organization founded in 1998 to advocate for scientific access to ancient human remains. FOAP supported the plaintiff scientists in their litigation, organized public information campaigns, and sought to build support for a position that scientific study of ancient remains served a legitimate and important public interest.

FOAP’s advocacy was part of a broader argument that NAGPRA’s application to very ancient remains — those from thousands of years before any traceable tribal continuity — was an overextension of the law. The organization argued that remains this old should be treated primarily as archaeological resources, available for study, rather than as the property of any present-day group.

This position attracted criticism from tribal advocates and from some within the anthropological community, who argued that it was using the language of scientific neutrality to advance what was essentially an argument for maintaining the status quo — the status quo in which Native American remains were subject to scientific study regardless of tribal wishes. They pointed to the history of how those collections had been assembled: through the excavation of burial sites without consent, through the collection of battlefield dead, through transfers from federal agencies and local sheriffs’ offices. Scientific neutrality was not a neutral position when the history of the field included decades of treating Native American remains as specimens.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.