Second, it is sensitive to what populations have been sampled. The finding that the Colville were the closest known relative of Kennewick Man was contingent on the set of Native American populations for which genome-wide data existed at the time of the study. If other tribes — the Umatilla, the Yakama, the Nez Perce, the Wanapum, or any of the hundreds of other Native American groups — had also been sequenced, the results might have been different. The Colville’s closest-known status was a finding about the available data, not a final determination of which present-day group had the closest relationship.

Third, population affinity is not cultural affiliation. Genetic similarity is a measure of biological descent. Cultural affiliation — the kind of connection that NAGPRA contemplates — involves shared cultural practices, beliefs, language, and community ties. These can correlate with genetic similarity, and often do. But they are not the same thing, and a population genetics study cannot directly measure them.

Willerslev and his team were explicit about all of these limitations. The public headlines were sometimes less careful. Statements that the DNA “proved” Kennewick Man was Native American, or that it “settled” the question of his origins, overstated what the genomic evidence could establish. What it established was important and significant. It was not quite what the boldest claims suggested.

—

## The Role of Media Coverage

The Kennewick case was extensively covered by American media from the moment of the first press conference in August 1996 to the final reburial in February 2017. The coverage had significant effects on how the case was understood by the public — and those effects were not always accurate.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.